SBUX vs MCD

Starbucks Corporation vs McDonald's Corporation · Consumer Cyclical · scored 2026-08-04

SBUXStarbucks Corporation50 Gem
VSEdge pick: SBUX — Starbucks Corporationhigher Gem Score
MCDMcDonald's Corporation45 Gem

Head-to-head

The numbers that matter, side by side. A star marks the stronger stock on each merit measure.

MeasureSBUXMCD
Gem Score50/100 ★45/100
Strategies agreeing3 ★1
Price$103.37$262.29
Market cap$118B$186B
Market regimeBullishBearish
Best-fit thesisCAN SLIMPiotroski F-Score
Win probability44% · 42%
Estimated edge+22.1% · +19.0%

Modeled from the GemStox stochastic + volatility models (order: SBUX · MCD). Not financial advice.

Strategy-thesis head-to-head

GemStox scores each stock across 14 independent investment theses. Here is where they differ.

Strategy thesisSBUXMCDΔ
GARP
61
★
46
+16
Mean Reversion
29
41
★
-12
Quality Compounder
52
53
★
-2
CAN SLIM
82
★
32
+49
Low-Vol Defensive
38
54
★
-16
Catalyst / Event
40
★
31
+9
Dividend Growth
22
22
+0
S-Curve Growth
23
34
★
-11
Piotroski F-Score
67
78
★
-11
Operating Leverage
25
25
+0
Net Payout Yield
40
40
+0

SBUX leads 3, MCD leads 5, 3 tied — of 11 comparable theses

Dimension by dimension

Average sub-signal score across valuation, quality, risk, growth, and momentum.

DimensionSBUXMCD
Valuation
50
★
40
Quality
56
★
54
Risk
44
54
★
Growth
51
★
39
Momentum & Technicals
37
★
28

How this comparison is computed

Every figure is computed from the same cached market + fundamentals data GemStox uses to score individual stocks — no two theses double-count. Try the free Stock Score calculator, read the full scoring methodology, or open either single-stock analysis above for the full 14-signal breakdown.

Free: compare any stocks in the live app →

Open the GemStox Compare tool and put any two (or up to ten) tickers head-to-head — live win probability, optimal position size, and pre-calculated stop/target levels. It's free to try: 3 comparisons a day, no account, then upgrade from $3 for unlimited.

Compare free in the app →

Educational comparison generated from cached market + fundamentals data as of 2026-08-04. Not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.